We can't forget James (sometimes goes by Jaime) King. She's been reported in several movie articles as having been in actual negotiations with the studio to play Supergirl. Who knows what will come of that, but its a credential that few others can claim.
velorian.org/jk023.jpg
velorian.org/james-king4.jpg
She's kind of skinny, but she does look a lot like the way the character is currently being drawn in the comic books.